I read this article about a man named Mark Edmonds who lives in Bourke Street Melbourne, who is complaining that the city is too loud.
I wont be as kind-hearted as Nicholas Jones (see his open letter down below) when I say…
- Mark Edmonds, you’re an idiot
- Get out of the city now, you selfish moronic fool!
- Mark Edmonds should be fined for making a false call to 000
- Suuport National SLAM Day
I lived in Lonsdale Street for a time, and yes there were ‘noise’ elements that we had to live with. Garbage Trucks emptying the bins at 3am, and Building Work that started at 6am seven days a week. Take your pick which one would annoy you the most, but thats what comes with living in the CBD. Other elements of living in the CBD were stepping out the back door and choosing any one of a thousand restaurants to eat at, walk to the cinema or theatre, stagger round the corner at 4am from the local nightclub.. ahh its a hard life living in the CBD, but someone has to do it.
But apparently not Mark Edmonds! What does he really think Melbourne is going to do? All bars and clubs to close early. Rearrange the garbage collection times to later in the day. Start the business day later, so traffic and transport does not affect his sleep patterns.
Mark Edmonds actually says: “residents had rights, regardless of whether the music venue was there first”. Yes, you’re right Mark, you have the right to either stay living in the city (and what comes with it), or piss off back to the burbs where you belong. Next minute we’ll hear he’s moved to the Dandenong’s and he’ll be complaining about bird noise!
Noise offends Bourke St resident
TheAge | By Jason Dowling
Mark Edmonds lived in the quiet leafy northern suburb of Eltham for 28 years before deciding to downsize when the children moved out, when he then bought an apartment in the CBD.
Mr Edmonds has enjoyed the services, transport connections and the views from his 28thstorey Bourke Street apartment – but the noise has been intolerable . In particular, Mr Edmonds said music from nearby venues was the main problem.
After four years Mr Edmonds and his wife had enough and spent $14,000 on double glazing . But the noise from the nearby venues did not stop. ‘‘ The heavy bass is not stopped by double glazing,’’ he says.
Mr Edmonds’ apartment windows face Bourke Street and he said the noise from a nightclub on Little Collins Street that operated well into the morning penetrated into his apartment.
He said residents had rights, regardless of whether the music venue was there first.
‘‘ The people who create the music need to consider the neighbours, whether they are new or otherwise,’’ he said.
‘‘ Have as much noise as you like, but the noise shouldn’t leave the premises.’
Mr Edmonds recently called triple-0 in the middle of the night because he was so fed up with the noise.
With the bottom end of the CBD set to experience an apartment boom in coming years with tens of thousands of new residents, Mr Edmonds said: ‘‘ There will be an uproar if the noise issue is not dealt with.’’
While there were 118 noise complaints to Melbourne City Council last financial year linked to music entertainment venues, there were more complaints about noise from building works, machinery such as airconditioners and barking dogs.
Music industry advocacy group Music Victoria is hoping to reduce the clash between residents and music venues with clearer planning, liquor and environment laws and the introduction of new ‘‘ cultural clusters’ ’ that create a win-win result for venues and residents.
Next month Monash University music industry expert Dr Shane Homan will discuss ‘‘ music, space and city’’ at a Melbourne symposium looking at creative clusters.
He said in Fortitude Valley in Brisbane authorities intervened to protect the music scene and made music in some areas the top planning priority.
Noise offends Bourke St resident
By JASON DOWLING
CITY EDITOR
Also see Open Letter below… (TGFT) its not just me..
An Open Letter To The Bourke St Resident Offended By Music Venues
Written by Nicholas Jones on 20 December 2012 | tonedeaf.com.au
Dear Mr. Edmonds,
This morning I read an article in The Age newspaper about the incessant problems you are having with noise from music venues in the Melbourne CBD with great interest. I too get aggravated when the noisy few have to ruin it for the rest of us.
It must have come as a great shock when you moved from the quiet fringe suburb of Eltham into the CBD of Melbourne only to be confronted with the hustle and bustle of the lively city culture around you.
Most look to move away from that activity as they look for a quiet escape in their twilight years, but I can tell you’ve never been much for following the crowd. You always have been a tad rebellious haven’t you?
So I can imagine your horror when you moved into the 28th floor of your high rise apartment only to realise that the CBD is a central hub for all kinds of late night and noisy culture.
Of course it’s an easy mistake to make, and I can see you have tried to embrace your new surroundings of music venues, bars, restaurants, shops, and noisy lane ways, by spending $14,000 on double glazing for your new apartment so you can really shut all that annoying culture out.
Seriously, who moves inner-city because of the culture anyway? Hippy nonsense.
In reading your plight against these insidious music venues, I couldn’t help but feel for your neighbours who live below the 28th floor you occupy, who no doubt must be dealing with even more noise problems.
So imagine my surprise when I found out that there was only 118 noise complaints to Melbourne City Council in the last financial year linked to music entertainment venues, less than the complaints about noise from building works, barking dogs, and airconditioners.
I can only assume you’ve somehow accidentally moved into a building for the deaf, otherwise I’m sure all your neighbours would be as outraged about this current situation as you are.
As someone who frequents music venues in the city, let me tell you though it’s worse than you could ever imagine. Did you know that most music venues also have airconditioners installed? No doubt they put little consideration into the impact this might have on future retirees moving into the city over the next decade.
I point that out, because as you say residents have rights, regardless of whether the music venue is there first. To quote you directly, “The people who create the music need to consider the neighbours, whether they are new or otherwise.”
You probably have no idea how right you are. Despite Fair Go 4 Live Music’s vigorous campaign to keep music in areas that saw big influxes of new residents, the agent of change principle has yet to be officially adopted by any of the inner-city councils in Melbourne.
Yes that’s right, there are scores of other concerned residents just like yourself, who for years have been moving inner-city to fight the good fight against any music venue who made the mistake of preempting your move into the area.
The agent of change principle is the idea that the party who changes the status quo, that is, they are the agent of the change, is the one responsible for dealing with any problems that arise.
For example, if apartments are built next to an existing music venue, the owners are responsible for sound proofing them, rather than the venue having to do it.
Perhaps that’s why they call it the Central Business District, and not the Central Retirement Village.
Of course I can see that you too are annoyed by the political paralysis of this issue. After all, if the agent of change principal had been applied, the developer of your building would have covered the $14,000 bill for double glazing your apartment during construction.
No doubt we’ll see you out supporting national SLAM Day so we can get these issues addressed. You remember SLAM right? The rally that saw 20,000 march down Bourke St. in 2010 to protest against the oppressive legislative environment surrounding music venues?
Perhaps you were too busy dialling 000 then too, after becoming fed up with that damn racket going past your apartment while you tried to watch that episode of Today Tonight you had recorded the night before.
At this point you might be thinking, ‘but music venue operators aren’t residents of the city, surely residents rights come first?’ Well, perhaps that’s why they call it the Central Business District, and not the Central Retirement Village.
But I digress. I really must thank you for bringing this ongoing struggle to the attention of thousands of readers of The Age, who have otherwise gone about their lives unaware of the knifes edge many inner-city venues face thanks to a handful of residents who’ve probably read The Princess & The Pea a few too many times.
Thanks to you, maybe next year will be the year that SLAM, Music Victoria, and a host of other passionate music campaigners from the music capital of Australia finally get the ongoing marginalisation of music venues put back on the agenda of local government.
In the meantime, just because you’ve traded in your leafy backyard in suburban Melbourne for an apartment in the heart of the city, doesn’t mean you should have to give up you your god given right to tell those goddamn kids to get off your lawn.
Sincerely,
Nicholas Jones.
An Open Letter To The Bourke St Resident Offended By Music Venues